- Four extreme-risk BHP tailings dams located at the Olympic Dam mine (SA), Whaleback iron ore mine (SA), Pilbara mine (WA), and the Leinster mine (WA)
- Two high-risk dams inside Rio Tinto’s Andoom and Torro mines at Weipa in Queensland
- Two high-risk dams inside Glencore’s Mount Isa Mines
What is the risk?Gavin Mudd, an associate professor of environmental engineering at RMIT University, said the history of tailings dam failures expanded beyond the potential impact to workers. Dr Mudd said that despite the risk of tailings dam contents flowing out causing death, irreversible environmental impact was also a catastrophic risk. “If you look at the Los Frailes tailings dam disaster in 1998, it didn’t kill anyone but it still caused a significant environmental impact,” Dr Mudd said. Tailings dams and storage facilities can pose a risk of failing due to their large structures being subjected to physical pressure from liquid and solid product. “Often they are metal-enriched ore bodies and that can cause significant public and environmental risk,” Dr Mudd said. “Even if there is no heavy metal, chemical, or radiation risk associated with tailings, we still need to be worried about its physical risk.” Australia’s history with tailings dam failures has not been exempt from controversy. More than a decade ago, the Burton coal mine south-west of Mackay contaminated surrounding land after its tailings dam was breached. The incident in 2007 was attributed to mining company Thiess inadequately monitoring the dam, along with failing to analyse the potential consequences.
No public risk to safety: minesDespite its tailings dams scoring a high-risk rating, a spokesperson for Mount Isa Mines told the ABC that it had complete confidence that all requirements had been met to ensure public safety. The spokesperson for the mine said flood events, extreme weather, and large earthquakes were all accounted for in its failure evaluations. Dr Mudd said he believed that Australia’s mining sector required robust regulation to not let its attitude lapse.
“It requires acknowledgement by the companies that yes, the probability may be low but the consequences are huge,” he said.
“That way we can look at what way this risk is being managed and if it is acceptable.”Originally published by ABC News.
- Speak to our team for a free demo of our Tailings Monitoring solution
- See how our solutions help manage industry stakeholder engagement and operator and regulator compliance requirements here